Home / Tabletop & Bar / Pumpkin Surprise Cookies, Set of 3

Pumpkin Surprise Cookies, Set of 3

Name: Pumpkin Surprise Cookies, Set of 3
Price: 17.26 USD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 4.6 (10 reviews)

(4.6)

Quantity

ADD TO CART

BUY IT NOW

Detail
Summary
Flavor Profile
- Buttery vanilla sugar cookies, sweet royal icing, sprinkle-filled centers
Why We Love It
- Play a sweet trick on Halloween revelers with our handmade cookies. The tiered treats have a hole in the middle filled with crunchy sprinkles shaped like bats, bones, eyeballs, tombstones and skulls. Made exclusively for us at Cookies By Shar in Florida, the classic vanilla sugar cookies are baked from scratch using the finest ingredients and hand decorated with vibrant royal icing. They arrive individually wrapped, ready for gift-giving, adding to goodie bags and embellishing place settings.
- A Williams Sonoma exclusive.
Net Weight
- 29.8 oz./845g total (9.94 oz./283g each).
- Set of 3.
- Individually wrapped.
- Shipped fresh.
Ingredients
- Cookies: Enriched unbleached flour (wheat flour, malted barley flour, niacin, iron, thiamin, riboflavin, folic acid), sugar, powdered sugar, butter (cream, natural flavor), egg, meringue powder, vanilla extract (water, alcohol [35%], sugar, vanilla bean extractives), Argo aluminum-free baking powder, water, sugar, one or more U.S. certified colors (Blue #1 [E133], Blue #2 [E132], Yellow #5 [E102], Yellow #6 [E110], Red #3 [E127], Red #40 [E129], titanium dioxide [E171]), mica pigment, vegetable gum, modified cornstarch, citric acid, less than 1/10 of 1% of: sodium benzoate (preservative), potassium sorbate (preservative).
- Sprinkles: Sugar, dextrose, cornstarch, non-hydrogenated palm oil, rice flour, dextrin, xanthan gum, magnesium stearate, artificial colors (FD&C Red #40, Red #3, Yellow #6, Blue #1), titanium dioxide, carnauba wax.
- Contains dairy, eggs, wheat/gluten.
- This product is prepared and packaged using machines that may come in contact with dairy, eggs, peanuts, tree nuts, wheat/gluten.
Shipping + Returns
Shipping Information

Please note that our made-to-order perishable food items are not eligible for next-day shipping – and they cannot be shipped outside the contiguous 48 states or to P.O. Boxes.

While we appreciate your order, we're not responsible for shipping delays due to unforeseen circumstances such as weather conditions or natural disasters.

We're also not responsible for any delay or failure to deliver due to an incorrect or incomplete shipping address.

Shipping Rates

The shipping rate varies depending on your order total and shipping destination. View Shipping Options and Charges.

Return Policy

We're not able to provide returns or cancellations on any food products, which are final sale items.

Please note that orders can't be cancelled once they have been processed or shipped.

View Full Returns Policy.
Customer Reviews

Hert********ska

Short and sweet: My dog stared at me the entire time I ate one. Not because he wanted it—because he knew I was committing a crime against deliciousness by not sharing. These are THAT good.

Prof. *************obi III

Brought these to a Friendsgiving setup and watched grown adults fight over the last cookie. The 'surprise' center made people go quiet—then happy. Texture? Chef’s kiss. Already planning my next order for Thanksgiving dessert table trolling.

Kie******han

Wow, these little orange cuties saved my last-minute teacher gift swap! Popped them in a mason jar with a ribbon and got compliments like I’m secretly Martha Stewart. Moist, flavorful, and way easier than baking from scratch—which, let’s be real, is my love language: minimal effort, maximum praise.

Mose******** II

Put these out during trick-or-treating and even the teens paused to say 'Whoa, cool!' The little pumpkin filling surprised everyone. Zero ghosts haunted my kitchen, which is a win.

Burn********ton

Cute for gifting, looked adorable in my daughter’s teacher gift basket. A bit sweet for my taste, but the pumpkin spice balance saved it from sugar overload. Would’ve liked more filling pop.

Crys********ecki

Solid snack game for my son’s school fall party. Kids loved the cute design and 'secret' center. One cookie cracked in transit, but tasted great anyway. Will buy again before Thanksgiving chaos.

Dev******ng

These pumpkin surprise cookies are like Halloween in a bite—spooky delicious! Perfect for my office 'Fall Fest' potluck. Coworkers thought I baked them myself. Joke's on them, I just opened a box and became an instant hero.

Mr. ********ona

These pumpkin surprise cookies are like Halloween in a bite—spooky delicious! Baked them at my niece’s party and the kids went full monster mode trying to steal extras. Perfect for fall gatherings or just pretending you’re a basic witch (no judgment). Will 100% haunt my pantry again.

Mr. To************runner

Used these as edible place cards at my autumn brunch—each guest got a cookie with their name tag. Everyone laughed and took pics. Flavor? Like pumpkin pie hugged a shortbread cookie. 10/10 host move.

Rus******ker

Solid cookie energy. Gave these to my coworkers during our 'Pumpkin Spice & Everything Nice' office theme week. One guy said it tasted like his grandma’s pie (high praise). Slight crumble issue during transport, but nothing duct tape and denial can’t fix. Great for gifting or stress-eating through autumn deadlines.

SEE ALL